Which Annual Non-Conference Rivalry Games are the Most Competitive?

By Amy Daughters -
Miami-Cincinnati

The Miami (OH)-Cincinnati series is nearly even. (David Kohl-USA TODAY Sports)

One scheduling element makes the SEC East more difficult than the SEC West—annual rivalry games with teams from other major conferences.

Where the entire SEC West can schedule non-league games with teams from any conference, Georgia, South Carolina, Kentucky and Florida all have a regular meeting with a big-time rival from the ACC.

This of course means that the four ACC schools involved must play an SEC team, every year.

The result is a major imbalance in strength of schedule—especially when it’s a competitive matchup—and it’s one of the reasons the SEC will require its members to play at least one “major non-conference game” beginning in 2016.

Here’s a look at 12 of the annual, non-conference rivalry games in college football, ranked by all-time competitiveness.

12. Colorado-Colorado State

All-Time Series: Colorado leads 63-22-2 (73.6%)

Last 10Colorado is 7-3, Colorado State last won in 2012.

Colorado and Colorado State’s 87-game series started in 1890. It has been dominated by the Buffaloes who hold an overwhelming 2,115 to 1,007 advantage in all-time points.

In 2014, the Buffaloes and Rams will meet in the season opener on Friday, Aug. 29 in Denver.

11. Purdue-Notre Dame

All-Time Series: Notre Dame leads 57-26-2 (68.2%)

Last 10Notre Dame is 9-1, Purdue hasn’t won since 2007 in West Lafayette.

Though Michigan-Notre Dame seems a lot sexier than the Irish taking on the Boilermakers, Notre Dame has faced Purdue twice as many times as it has the Wolverines.

This year’s meeting—a Week 3 game in Indianapolis—marks the 85th time that the Boilermakers and Irish have battled for the Shillelagh Trophy (not to be confused with the Jeweled Shillelagh that Notre Dame and USC play for).

10. New Mexico-New Mexico State

All-Time Series: New Mexico leads 68-31-5 (67.8%)

Last 10New Mexico is 7-3, New Mexico State last won in 2011 in Albuquerque.

The Lobos and Aggies first clashed on a football field in 1894 in Albuquerque, a game New Mexico won 18-6.

The 105th meeting between New Mexico and New Mexico State is slated for Saturday, Sept. 20 at Aggie Memorial Stadium in Las Cruces.

9. Iowa State-Iowa

All-Time Series: Iowa leads 40-21 (65.6%)

Last 10Iowa is 6-4 but Iowa State has won two of the last three.

Iowa and Iowa State’s 61-year old series kicked off in 1894 when the Cyclones scored a 16-8 win in Iowa City.

The Cyclones and Hawkeyes will battle for this year’s Cy-Hawk Trophy on Saturday, Sept. 13 in Iowa City.

8. Georgia-Georgia Tech

All-Time Series: Georgia leads 64-39-5 (61.6%)

Last 10Georgia is 9-1, Georgia Tech’s last win was in 2008 in Athens.

Georgia and Georgia Tech have been dishing each other a heaping helping of “Clean, Old-Fashioned Hate” since 1893.

The rivalry will be celebrated for the 109th time this season when the Yellow Jackets travel an hour northeast to Athens to face the Bulldogs on Saturday, Nov. 29.

7. Marshall-Ohio

All-Time Series: Ohio leads 32-19-6 (61.4%)

Last 10Marshall is 6-4 but have lost the last three straight.

The Thundering Herd and the Bobcats first squared off to “Battle for the Bell” in 1905 and have met 57 times since then.

This season Ohio will travel across the state line to Marshall on Saturday, Sept. 13 for a Week 3 non-conference showdown.

6. South Carolina-Clemson

All-Time Series: Clemson leads 65-42-4 (60.4%)

Last 10South Carolina is 6-4 and have won the last five straight.

The Palmetto Bowl kicked off in 1896 when the Gamecocks beat the Tigers 12-6 in Columbia. The game was played exclusively in Columbia until 1960, when the venue began to alternate with Clemson.

The 112th edition of this storied rivalry is scheduled for Saturday, Nov. 29 when South Carolina will travel to Clemson.

5. Florida-Florida State

All-Time Series: Florida leads 34-22-2 (60.3%)

Last 10Florida is 7-3, but Florida State has won three of the last four.

A relatively new rivalry, the Gators and Seminoles first squared off in 1958 in Gainesville, a game Florida won 21-7.

The 59th meeting between the two powerhouses from the Sunshine State will happen in this season’s finale, Saturday, Nov. 29 in Tallahassee.

4. USC-Notre Dame

All-Time Series: Notre Dame leads 45-35-5 (55.9%)

Last 10USC is 7-3 but Notre Dame has won two of the last three.

USC and Notre Dame have been duking it out for the Jeweled Shillelagh since they first met in Los Angeles in 1926, a contest the Irish won 13-12.

In 2014, the two powerhouses will clash for the 86th time when the Irish travel to the West Coast to face the Trojans in the regular-season finale on Saturday, Nov. 29.

3. Louisville-Kentucky

All-Time Series: Kentucky leads 14-12 (53.8%).

Last 10Louisville is 6-4 and has won three straight.

The Cardinals and Wildcats have played for Governor’s Cup honors on 26 occasions. The series began in 1912 and after six early meetings took a 70-year hiatus until it was re-established in 1994.

In 2014, Louisville and Kentucky will play for in-state bragging rights on Saturday, Nov. 29 in Louisville.

2. SMU-TCU

All-Time Series: TCU leads 46-40-7 (53.2%).

Last 10TCU is 8-2, SMU hasn’t won since 2011 in Fort Worth, Texas.

Though SMU and TCU spent almost 80 years as fellow members of the Southwest and then Western Athletic Conferences, ever since 2001 they’ve met as non-conference foes.

The Mustangs and Horned Frogs will fight for possession of the Iron Skillet for the 94th time on Saturday, Sept. 27 in Dallas.

1. Cincinnati-Miami (OH)

All-Time Series: Miami (OH) leads 59-52-7 (53%)

Last 10Cincinnati is 9-1, Miami last won in 2005 in Oxford, Ohio.

The Battle for the Victory Bell dates all the way back to 1888, when Miami and Cincinnati’s first game ended in a scoreless tie in Oxford, Ohio.

Since then, the two programs have met 118 times resulting in what is one of the most closely-contested long-term rivalries.

In 2014, the RedHawks will travel 45 minutes south to Cincinnati to face the Bearcats on Saturday, Sept. 20.

Follow FBSchedules.com on Facebook, Twitter, and Google+Subscribe via Email
Categories: NCAA, Strength of Schedule

26 Comments to Which Annual Non-Conference Rivalry Games are the Most Competitive?

  1. Chip Plglar said....

    U rank Louisville/ Kentucky over USC/ Notre Same? C’mon man

    May 2, 2014 at 9:11 pm
    • Atlanta Mafia said....

      Chip, they call it math! Look at his % included in the rankings.
      Otherwise, I would make FSU – Florida as #1.

      May 2, 2014 at 9:25 pm
    • Kevin Kelley said....

      The games are ranked by winning percentage. The closer the series, the higher the ranking.

      May 2, 2014 at 10:30 pm
  2. ND said....

    Uh, Notre Dame has won three of the last four over the trojans.

    May 2, 2014 at 10:16 pm
  3. tim said....

    What about BYU Utah

    May 3, 2014 at 12:40 am
  4. @dbrunstheworld said....

    Thanks for the article. In response to Tim, BYU does have an annual series that is competitive now in Boise State and an annual series fairly even over the long-term with Utah State.

    May 3, 2014 at 1:59 pm
  5. Robert Corbett said....

    Technically, Army-Navy is not a conference game. Navy leads the series 58-49-7, which is 58% and would rank it #5 on the list.

    May 3, 2014 at 3:34 pm
    • Kevin Kelley said....

      Right, it’s not a non-conference game either for purposes of this article since both are Independents.

      May 3, 2014 at 8:39 pm
    • Brock said....

      Independents aren’t in a conference, so every game they play is by default a non-conference game. Army-Navy is a non-conference game, and it’s pretty incredible that they didn’t make this list.

      May 5, 2014 at 1:44 pm
    • Kevin Kelley said....

      The intro specifically mentions conference teams having to play non-conference rivals. That’s what this article is about, nothing more.

      May 5, 2014 at 3:06 pm
  6. Andy Coffaro said....

    Cool idea for an article Amy!

    May 4, 2014 at 10:22 am
    • Brock said....

      Cool idea, but questionable execution.

      Purdue-Notre Dame is included even though they aren’t playing each other next year (and thus, their rivalry isn’t “annual”), yet BYU-Utah is left off just because they aren’t playing this year for the first time since World War II.

      Army-Navy is left off the list despite not playing in a conference together.

      May 5, 2014 at 1:49 pm
    • Kevin Kelley said....

      PUR-ND play this year, which is a requirement of the article as the date is listed for each game.

      Army-Navy is not an “out of conference” game for purposes of the article.

      May 5, 2014 at 3:04 pm
  7. r.h.spedding said....

    indiana -purdue the old oaken bucket

    May 5, 2014 at 11:54 am
    • Phil said....

      That’s a conference rivalry game, the headline of the article clearly states non-conference rivalry games

      May 5, 2014 at 3:49 pm
  8. Vince said....

    No doubt the Cincinnati-Miami, Ohio rivalry is the oldest (118 years) and most intense of those listed. In one game in 1923 a Cincinnati player died, Jimmy Nippert. The university named the stadium after Jimmy and is known today as Nippert Stadium. I think the Cincinnati-Miami, Ohio rivalry was the best choice by the author Amy Daughters. Nice photo too by the way !!!

    May 7, 2014 at 7:53 am
  9. Dan said....

    I assume you’re going by teams currently playing, or played last year. You will have to revise your findings staring in 2016, as the Pitt-Penn State rivalry will be in your top 2 or 3.
    48-42-4 (53.3%). Also, one of the oldest, started in 1893. Was right in the mix in the 70′s, 80′s and 90′s as one of the top rivalry games in college football. Always at the top of ratings, and many times in the late 70′s and early 80′s, the teams were ranked #1 and #2.

    JoePa nixed the series in the early 90′s because of petty selfishness. Ah, actually in fairness, Pitt had some fault in it as well, joining the Big East and not letting Penn State in.

    Now, that JoePa is gone, the series starts up again in 2016. I can wait for you revised article in 2 years.

    ps, might want to look up the Oklahoma-Nebraska series, one of the best college football ever had. I know, they no longer play, and that is a shame.

    May 7, 2014 at 4:32 pm
  10. Dan said....

    Oklahoma v. Nebraska, 45-38-3 (54%). Pretty good also.

    May 7, 2014 at 6:06 pm
  11. Danny Greene said....

    Aren’t you forgetting something? FSU-MIAMI?

    May 7, 2014 at 10:38 pm
    • Vince said....

      Non Conference Dan and Danny Greene? What gives? Also, take note Kevin, Dan makes a good point about the Pitt-Penn State rivalry. Some reason, that’s not listed???

      May 8, 2014 at 8:46 am
  12. Danny Greene said....

    From before the canes joined the ACC

    May 7, 2014 at 10:39 pm

Leave a Reply